Two years ago, when
we had to purchase private health insurance for a brief period, I had my first brush
with the Affordable Care Act. I learned that I would be required to purchase a
plan swollen with benefits that I wouldn't use. Then I learned that I would pay thousands in
monthly premiums and even higher deductibles before I would experience one dime of coverage.
Our alternative while
we waited for new employer coverage was to purchase a slimmer, but
non-compliant plan, and be taxed 1% of income for each month that we carried it.
Did I resent this
requirement? I did. Did I resent the ACA? I did. Did I offset the feeling of having something forced down my throat with gratitude for the sake of others who would not otherwise be covered? Eventually. Not at first, I didn't.
When Trump came
along and said that five minutes after taking office he'd dump the ACA, did I
vote for him?
I did not.
My disgust with Trump's mindset, temperament, attitude toward anyone not like him, poor self-control and frat-boy maturity reminded me of my compassion for others who struggle, which was greater than my disgust at being forced to purchase something I didn't need.
I went to bed on election
night before Trump won, but not before I saw Hillary lose the election one state at a time, and realized that we were
seeing for the first time, the real number of
Americans who had found some voice in Trump's.
At 5:40 yesterday morning,
before I read a text, a tweet, an email or column, I pulled up the Washington
Post for the headline, and there it was:
TRUMP TRIUMPH.
I expected that at least some
of this would be laid at the feet of FBI director James Comey. It was.
I expected the population
that voted for Trump would be eviscerated in the media. It was.
Finally, now, one day and a better night's sleep later, we appear to be shutting up long enough to
understand what we've done to create the population we didn't see coming.
We could have seen it coming
back in September, when Hillary Clinton, face and voice of the liberal elite, made
her "deplorables" comment, a horribly considered, "them and
us" message meant to liken those drawn to any part of Trump's message to the worst of his supporters.
If Trump did irreparable
damage to his campaign with his raunchy Access Hollywood expose, Hillary did maybe as
much when she characterized the dilemma of people not like her in such dismissive
terms.
Her followers
included fence-walkers – the once-loyal but now conflicted Obama supporter,
crushed by economic strain, unwilling to look away from a Clinton presidency
quite yet, but repelled by the elitist rhetoric. She could have alienated more
people with that comment only if she'd pushed them off the fence herself.
Right out loud, I said, "Oh God, you shouldn't have said that." Because while I hated Trump's
comments, I wasn't surprised by them. But that spray of bullets from
Hillary, was more than upsetting, it was honest, and not in a good
way.
I felt manipulated and used by the ACA. Was I a "deplorable"? No, but did any campaign language from that side try hard enough to
make the distinction?
When you screw with people's
money or futures or economic viability or feeling of safety and assume they
will continue to be other-focused, and not self-preserving in their ideals, you get
unhappily surprised when the way to protect their interests presents itself on election day. .
What's more, I don't think
Trump, in the beginning even expected to do more than make a point. I think he
stumbled upon his base of frustrated, marginalized, fed-up Americans more than
he cultivated it. But there they were,
all those "deplorables," misunderstood and forgotten by everyone and
what Trump, king of the deplorables did about this was say, "Hand me that
ladle and bullhorn."
Stir the pot he did, enraging
his supporters – from the infantile to the mature – with his own big fat
messages of "them and us":
"We're losing our homes,
our identity, our jobs, our country. Are we going to let them get away with
that?"
Storms of outrage and ridicule rained down on Trump and his
supporters, and he only dug in further. His signature bombast became dangerous,
his polarizing style threatening. He had
his gang, and his gang had gangs and they powered through, not only willing
to offend protesters, but delighting in it when they did.
There were comparisons to
Hitler. There were seething characterizations of Trump supporters that only
drew them closer to their leader for solace. They were all in it together.
On Tuesday night, "they"
hopped into their camo-wear and pick up trucks, and plowed through
"us."
Except that they didn't.
A bunch of profane, crass
guys with obscene t-shirts and guts and mud flaps with pole dancers on them
didn't do this to us.
We did this to us.
We loathed a public Trump,
vocally, viciously, but we ignored that many, many people were in the kind
of straits that would allow them to find agreement with the softer ideas of a dialed-down Trump.
And as we've seen, in the
minds of some deplorables, Hillary's transgressions were as morally difficult to reconcile as Trump's comments about women were sickening to listen to.
I know that most of us had no
question about the candidate who was best for us. I didn't reject Hillary
for her flaws, nor did I give her my vote because I thought it was expected of me as an "adorable." I voted for Hillary because
I wanted a kick-ass, competent, savvy woman in the white house, AND because I loathed Donald Trump for the truly awful things he's said, and has said he'd do.
I agree with those who have attributed this wildly unexpected turn to the Trumpets Anonymous, shamed away from showing themselves in the pre-election numbers, but who quietly closed the curtain,
took out their anonymity, and voted against Hillary.
If that's true, and it was
certainly true when we elected cowboy George, what does it say about us, that
we intimidate others or are intimidated by them into hiding our politics?
Trump didn't win the people
as much as he carried their
bullhorn. It was loud enough to be heard through that closet door, where
the other Trump supporters gathered, to choose the best of the
bad.
I can soothe my soul by remembering in the future: while we differ out loud, we often agree in
the privacy of our hearts. May all our hearts open to the possibility of a presidency that will not hurt us, but unite us. We have that one thing to hope for, in common, finally.
May that be what the hell happens now.